My perspective on Jewish life, chinuch/parenting, psychology, social issues, health ...
Oct 17, 2013
ADD/ADHD Revisited
I haven't written about ADD/ADHD in too long, considering how often it comes up in frum publications and talks. Previous posts on the subject include:
Refreshing! and
Diagnosis: Toddleritis and
This is ADHD? and
ADD - Attention Deficit Disorder - When Parents' Attention is Deficient .
This is from a letter written by a mother to a frum women's publication:
I have two children with ADHD (and five without) ... I try with every fiber of my being to be supportive and nurturing towards my sons. I understand their therapists' pleas for me to be patient and not to let everything get to me, and I can look away, but my other children can't. When my 14 year old daughter completed a book report that she worked on for two weeks and then her brother came in and ripped it to shreds in a fit, it was difficult for me to comfort my daughter. When she begs me, "Why do you let him? He never learns!" something inside me wants to snap. She's right. He's right.
And into all this walks the therapist and says, "Keep your cool - he'll come around one day, and we're giving him tools." When he comes around, I might have five other bitter and angry and misunderstood kids. They know their brother has his issues and they are kind and gracious, but sometimes they feel he ruins their lives. My older son is medicated and in therapy and he has come a long way, but he has kicked more holes in the wall than we can ever fill.
First, I will say that my heart does go out to her. She is a mother who cares. Deeply. And it sounds like she is trying to be a superlative parent. My protest is not about her, but about a medical world that is destroying kids and their families as this mother describes.
Although the mother does not say how old her boys are, they are obviously not two or she wouldn't be medicating and therapizing them. How can our hearts not go out to parents who are told to be "supportive and nurturing" while not being told to discipline their children and how to do so to achieve results?
A child is destructive and all the therapist has to offer is a request for patience and reassurance about the distant future? The mother is realizing that this approach is undermining the entire household and is doing nothing to improve the situation.
The French have very little ADHD because they give their children lots of structure and discipline. It could be that disorganized adults don't do that for their children and children thrive best on a schedule and routine.
ReplyDelete